Skip navigation.

... Midlife Improvement

Search LifeTwo:

Get Our Newsletter!

Stay up to date on midlife issues -- subscribe to our monthly email newsletter (you can easily unsubscribe later)!

Email address:

Visit Our Store!

Visit our store at Amazon to see books and other products we recommend -- like this:

Your LifeTwo

In this area, registered users see recommendations, set bookmarks, and track what their buddies are up to. For more on the benefits of registering, go here.

User login

Advertising Supplied By:

twitter_logo

Follow us on Twitter and get tweets when new posts go up! Click on the Twitter logo to go to our page at Twitter, and then click the "follow" button.

Subscribe in a Reader:

XML feed

Use the icon above to subscribe to LifeTwo's Home Page in a reader like My Yahoo or Google Reader (see this page to learn more about RSS and for information on our other feeds). Or if you use one of the following services, just click on its icon:

Add to Google

Add to My Yahoo!

Add to My AOL


New On LifeTwo's Homepage

Recent Discussions

Talking It Out Isn't Necessarily The Best Thing

Wesley's picture

The conventional wisdom that the best way to cope after a traumatic or disturbing event is to talk about it may be wrong--at least for some people. How many times have you heard that the best course of action is to talk about it? But research is showing that there can be downsides to this approach. According to an article in the Los Angeles Times(7/28/08 print edition only):

Some people have periods of what psychologists call 'healthy denial.' Like Scarlet O'Hara, they cope by promising themselves to think about it tomorrow. Being pushed to give voice to their worst reactions too soon could embed the worst of it in memory and cause them to dwell on the tradegy.

Research is showing that urging those who do not to talk to go against their instincts could do more harm than good. This coincides with other mental health research that showed that "some things are better left unsaid."

It should be noted that none of this negates the value of expressing emotions and thoughts when it feels right. What looks like denial might in reality be people distracting themselves until they have gained enough strength or perspective to deal with it.

4.5
 
 

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Anonymous's picture

Right on! I don't want to hear it!

Instead of "talking it out" how about "thinking it through?" This country needs more stoicism and less Dr. Phil.

And this blog needs a Digg button.

Anonymous's picture

I like to talk it out

I think it's probably right, what the article is saying. If I have a problem, I've been known to think about it a lot, get bogged down in it and bore my husband with it. Well, I stopped talking to him about things.

The upside of thinking about things, such as regrets, failures, bad feelings about some issue or other, is that in the end I have learned something and it can't bother me anymore. I think of it as working through my dharma or something like that. I no longer get jealous if my husband is around women. I have forgiven and forgotten several regretful incidents in my youth. I understand when others are having problems because I've been there and now I have empathy. I realize that people don't always know what they're doing and they make mistakes.

I feel embarrassed when I am busy thinking and talking about something and then someone says, "Get over it." It's uncaring and shallow and judgmental. But that doesn't mean their way of coping isn't right. People who take their frustrations out at the gym are in shape as well as not dwelling on things.

I've come out of my thinking periods with new ideas for what's possible. I think if I don't carefully look at what I really want, I'll just take some advice I read on the internet and find myself back on square one.

But...when I hear someone else ruminating about a problem, I too don't want to hear it.

Lisa

Anonymous's picture

Silence is not merely the absence of speech

Very thought provoking. Pondering in silence may be much more healing....Nancy Mehegan

Post new comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.